ATTENTION- FORMER CHIEF JUSTICE, SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

To,

Justice R S Lodha,

Supreme Court committee,

Overseeing working of Medical Council of India,

Delhi.

Subject-  Requesting your intervention in matter of ‘cut- practice’ in medicine

Respected Sir,

I read in the newspaper that a committee under your able chairmanship has been set up to study and monitor the working of Medical Council of India, with particular reference to corrupt practices. I am writing this letter with the hope that something may be done about  ‘cut- practice’ in the medical profession.

‘Cut practice’ is the system of earning commission for referring patients to a particular doctor or medical organisation. It undermines medical care and harms the patient. Hence, it must be stopped as soon as possible. Cut- practice is labelled ‘unethical’ but the MCI or Maharashtra Medical Council have no set procedures to investigate or punish violations. It is not ‘illegal’ as there is no law against it.

 In 2013 Dr Bawaskar filed a complaint in the Maharashtra Medical Council about one such instance. Though the fact of giving cuts in this case was proved and admitted to by the defendent, no action can be taken on basis of a technicality- that the cut was issued not by an individual doctor but by a medical organisation. In effect, it seems that cut-practice is unethical for individuals but a legitimate business practice for groups of individuals. This can only be termed as a travesty. The case is now stuck at this point at the Mumbai High Court. Meanwhile, the Medical Council of India has passed a circular stating expressly that its mandate is only to act against individual registered doctors and not against organised group of doctors, further bolstering the above case. (I can provide you the details, if you wish. Meanwhile, you may see them on my blog mentordoc@blogspot.com)

 These developments are dangerous for the public. It endangers the ability to choose medical treatment that is competent and affordable. The most important intervention would be to bring medical organisations, associations and commercial healthcare entities under regulation by making registration under medical councils mandatory. Medical ethics and laws should be the same for individuals and groups.

I, therefore request you to study this matter deeply. With your knowledge, experience and authority you may be able to suggest a suitable remedy to stem this rot. Sir, an effective action will bring succour to all Indians. I exhort you to please do something in this matter.

I also request you to kindly acknowledge this letter, at least through email.

With much anticipation

Sincerely,

Dr Vani Kulhalli

(I HAVE POSTED ON BLOG BECAUSE EVEN AFTER 3 mts of SEARCHING I WAS UNABLE TO GET THE POSTAL OR MAIL ADDRESS. I JUST HOPE THIS WORKS.)